It seems hard to believe that all of my thoughts are merely biological in nature, being nothing more than neurotransmitters and the sort. But then, maybe we're more like a computer where those biological components merely carry information, in who knows what form. But it raises the question of what creates those thoughts, in whatever form they take. Pure biology surely cannot account for all of my thoughts, but then, why do I think what I do? Where do these thoughts come from; they must have some origin and, if it's not biological, then what is it? Perhaps I am merely a spirit or some such thing trapped in this biological body, but then why am I trapped in such a body? And not only why, but how? How would it be possible to trap a spirit in a body in the first place, and not only trap, but let it control that body? What is it that controls my body, what is this thing that I call me?
If I am indeed a spirit, why would I be here? To answer that it might be good to see what we could get out of living. Over time my body will change, and I will have to accomodate it. Over time my spirit would change, it would be shaped by the world in which it lives, in which it experiences. So, perhaps I am here to be changed, whether for good or ill I have no idea. Or maybe there is no purpose, things are as they are for no apparent reason. Or maybe, just maybe, it's sort of like a symbiotic relation; perhaps the spirit can only survive as long as the body survives, or perhaps the spirit can only sense and experience things and maybe even only be able to think when it is in a body, and the body benefits by having something to guide it well through life.
The how, though, is much more problematic. How could a bodiless spirit even come in contact with a physical body, much less be trapped in it and given control of that body? There would have to be some kind of link that's both physical and spiritual at the same time. Thoughts are merely physical encodings carried by neurotransmitters, the origins of those encodings coming from the spirit. So, the link would have to be in the encoding process. But how does that information convert from spiritual to physical?
Then again, maybe it is purely biological. It still begs the questions of how and why, though. Being purely biological it is a self-satisfying loop, keeping within one system, but how? I mean, sensors in my stomach tells me when it's empty, making me feel hungry, but what about all the thoughts, such as these, that don't seem to have any biological basis. The former is based on an action-reaction theory, but surely not everything is an action or a reaction. I mean, why do I wonder what I wonder? Is it merely a reaction based on some action? What if it's something else entirely? What is it that makes matter tick, make it wonder about things? Is that all it really is, matter wondering about itself? But then we already have that theory, matter that wonders about itself is called Dust, at least according to Philip Pullman. But not everything was Dust, Dust just seemed to cling to people and things made by them, being no more part of the body than a spirit. That would solve the problem of how a spirit would connect with a body, but it doesn't explain how these things moved around or why. In any event, the Dust or whatever seems to stay in my body evolving over time, yet staying consistent enough to seem to be the same. And it still begs the question of why.
Maybe I'm looking at this wrong. Maybe the message carried in the neurotransmitters are self-encoding pieces of matter. While self-encoding is a nice thought, why do they encode what they encode, and why is there a singular sense of self? Perhaps the messengers create their messages based on what data it's recieved from the body, but then why is there usually, if not always, a singular line of thought? It's one thing to say that the body can't handle that, but if the message is there, why wouldn't it be processed? And what would process it if it needed processing? Perhaps there is a hierarachy of Dust, but wouldn't it all need a physical location for it all to happen? And all of it seems rather far fetched, as there seems to be an I in the singular form, not a multiplicity of problem-solving, thinking things.
So, what is the answer? If thoughts are spiritual in origin, how does the spirit connect with the body? If it's purely biological, why do I think what I do and how is it processed? And if it's not either, what is it?
2/17/2008
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)